Aren’t things supposed to get better from one generation to another? Aren’t people supposed to ever learn? Or maybe it’s another thing altogether: maybe by repeating the mistakes of the past we learn to accept the limits of our predecessors and acknowledge their humanity, and as a result, we're able to forgive ourselves the inevitable repeated mistakes.
My father liked science experiments, so we had to like science experiments. A former meteorologist in the military, he liked to discuss cloud shapes. He liked politics, so we had to talk about politics. He liked to talk about his family history, so we had to memorize names. And in all of these things and in countless others, I’d failed him.
His disappointed face is something I always carry with me. Always the same routine. A sigh, his head down, an angry expression, and the ultimate blow: “Why do you hate your father?”
“I don’t hate you,” I used to say.
“Yes, you do. Otherwise you would do what I told you to do.”
I got used to that after a while, learning that this phrase meant the end of me having to do something I hated doing. Hearing him tell me I hated him meant I no longer had to know the difference between a Cumulonimbus and a Cumulus, I didn’t have to role-play as a journalist interviewing his favorite politician, and I didn’t have to learn about all the relatives who died in the Holocaust. That “Why do you hate your father” meant one thing: I was free.
But there was also pain associated with this sentence, and many times I’d tried to argue and explain that, well, there were things I’d rather do than be his lab-partner; that I was just a kid, and who cares about cloud-classifications when you can look at clouds for hours and find animals and monsters? And that, again, I didn’t hate him.
So why am I writing this now? Because the other day the new guy was having a good time with his mother—feeding, and playing, and smiling—and then she passed him to me when she went to take a shower. Now, as soon as I took him and started singing my favorite childhood song, his expression changed to suspicion, which soon turned to sadness. Soon, he was crying with the most painful, offended expression on his face. And I looked at him cry and thought about how happy he was with his mother just a few minutes earlier, and how come I couldn’t make him happy even though I sang him a beautiful song, and then I said, “Why do you hate your father?”